HomePoliticalUS Congress Report Highlights Possible Constitutional Violations in India's Citizenship Amendment Act

US Congress Report Highlights Possible Constitutional Violations in India’s Citizenship Amendment Act

Published on

TRENDING NEWS TOPIC

A report published by an independent research wing of the US Congress has indicated that certain provisions of the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) enacted this year may potentially violate India’s Constitution. The CAA, which amends the 1955 Citizenship Act, aims to provide a path to citizenship for undocumented non-Muslim migrants from Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan who entered India before December 31, 2014.

According to the Congressional Research Service (CRS) report, “The CAA’s key provisions — allowing immigrants of six religions from three countries a path to citizenship while excluding Muslims — may violate certain Articles of the Indian Constitution.” This concern is heightened when considering the planned National Register of Citizens (NRC), as both measures combined could potentially jeopardize the rights of India’s Muslim population.

Critics argue that these actions suggest that Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is pursuing a Hindu majoritarian agenda at odds with India’s officially secular republic status and international human rights norms. The CRS report suggests that the timing of implementing the CAA during BJP’s re-election campaign raises suspicions about political motivations.

Pointing out flaws in selectively protecting members of “approved” religions through this legislation, critics warn against undermining India’s secular ethos and establishing what they call “‘an ethnic democracy’ equating the Hindu-majority community with the nation,” effectively relegating others to second-class status.

While providing reports for congressional decision-making purposes only and not representing official congressional views, CRS reports carry significant influence within US policymaking circles.

The Biden administration has previously expressed concerns regarding notification of implementation for India’s controversial law. It has stated its close monitoring of developments surrounding this legislation.

India has consistently dismissed international criticism regarding discrimination and has maintained that the CAA’s primary goal is to grant citizenship. The Indian government has emphasized in a statement that no citizen of the country would lose their citizenship due to this legislation.

While the debate over the constitutional implications and potential marginalization of religious communities continues, critics are closely watching how this law will unfold and its impact on India’s social fabric.

Latest articles

Moto G85 5G: A Feature-Packed Budget Smartphone That Defies Expectations

Motorola’s latest offering, the Moto G85 5G, is a new addition to the G-series...

Bombay High Court Steps in After Sexual Assault of Two Young Girls at Badlapur School Sparks Outrage

The Bombay High Court has taken swift action, initiating a suo motu hearing in...

Mehbooba Mufti fake allegation on poll rigging in Anantnag–Rajouri seat

The Anantnag Police stated that detentions are minimal and only involve individuals with a...

Grandfather Arrested in Pune Porsche Case for Wrongful Confinement of Family Driver

The grandfather of the 17-year-old boy who allegedly killed two IT professionals with his...

More like this

Moto G85 5G: A Feature-Packed Budget Smartphone That Defies Expectations

Motorola’s latest offering, the Moto G85 5G, is a new addition to the G-series...

Bombay High Court Steps in After Sexual Assault of Two Young Girls at Badlapur School Sparks Outrage

The Bombay High Court has taken swift action, initiating a suo motu hearing in...

Mehbooba Mufti fake allegation on poll rigging in Anantnag–Rajouri seat

The Anantnag Police stated that detentions are minimal and only involve individuals with a...